Across four calls one change stands out: Coherent is no longer a collection of photonics businesses but a capacity-limited supplier to AI data centres. Demand is booked into 2028; what decides revenue now is how fast its own factories turn out lasers. How much of the 2028 order book is firm purchase orders?
Demand is no longer the constraint; production is.
Management reported record bookings in three straight quarters and orders reaching into calendar 2028; the limit, it said, is laser output rather than customer appetite. Growth is now an execution number. Is indium phosphide still the binding constraint this quarter?
The 6-inch indium phosphide ramp does two jobs at once.
Output doubling landed early and yields beat the mature older lines. A 6-inch wafer yields four times the chips at half the cost, so the same ramp lifts how much it ships and what each shipment earns.
Capacity spending has outrun the cash the business makes.
Capital spending hit $563 million in one quarter against $69 million of cash from operations, and free cash flow was negative by over $1 billion in FY2026. If orders land slower, it is left holding stock and plants built for demand. How much of the FY2026 capital spending went into indium phosphide?
Bullish
Capacity ramp sets growth
The bull case is that demand exceeds what Coherent can build, so revenue growth depends mainly on how fast indium phosphide capacity comes online.
New optical platforms
Optical circuit switching and co-packaged optics add new sales layers on top of transceivers, widening the company's share of optical content in AI networks.
Margins and balance sheet
Cheaper six-inch wafer production plus a much smaller debt load should let earnings grow faster than sales, which is the core of the profitability case.
Bearish
AI customer concentration
The bear case is that a handful of AI data center buyers drive most of the growth, so any pause in their network spending would hit revenue quickly.
Cash tied up in capacity
Capital spending has outrun cash generation, so the payback on new factories depends on demand holding up long enough to fill the added capacity.
Pricing fixed in contracts
Long-term supply agreements fix prices for years, which limits how much Coherent can earn if shortages persist or if its own costs move against it.