The Progressive Corporation

PGR · NYSE · USD

Analysis

Last 4 earnings calls · through Q2 FY2026

Progressive is now the biggest US auto insurer and still very profitable, but growth is slowing as the market softens. It is trading profit per policy for volume and betting the next leg on a repaired property business. How much pricing power is left in the states where it cut auto rates?

  • Progressive is the biggest US auto insurer now, and its growth is slowing.

    It took about 75% of the industry's premium growth in 2025, but Personal Lines policies are growing at half the pace of a year earlier as competitors take on risk again. That lead is now the thing it has to defend. Which competitors took back the auto share Progressive lost this year?

  • Management is deliberately trading profit per policy for volume.

    It cut auto rates in 16 states covering over a third of its premium and raised advertising 16% in the quarter. Cost per sale is under target, so it is buying profitable growth - but earnings per policy fall unless the customers show up.

  • Property is fixed, and it is the key to the next leg of growth.

    Property went from losing money to a 75 combined ratio in 2025. The states it now calls healthy enough to grow in more than doubled, to 41. But agent-sold bundles stalled during that fix, and win rates on comparison sites are down. How many bundled households has the property fix actually added?

Bullish
  • Pricing and data scale
    Progressive's scale in pricing data lets it gain market share and earn an underwriting profit at the same time, which few competitors have managed through a full cycle.
  • Bundled household expansion
    A repaired property business gives the company a credible home product to pair with auto, opening the bundled segment where its share is smallest.
  • Trading margin for unit growth
    Because the company prices well below its own target combined ratio, it can cut rates to win policies without abandoning its long-run underwriting discipline.
Bearish
  • Soft market price competition
    The industry has moved from raising prices to cutting them, so recent margins depend on competitors staying disciplined rather than on anything Progressive controls.
  • Policy growth is slowing
    Growth has come off its peak and customers are shopping more, so holding unit growth now costs more advertising and more price reductions.
  • Bundling gap in agency channel
    Most bundled auto business is still sold through agents, where the company's share is low and its property overhaul held bundled policies flat.
See the full bull & bear case
PoliticiansInstitutionsInsiders
PoliticianTransactionAmountTradedFiled
Donald Trump
Republican · Executive
Purchase≥$250KAug 21Oct 8
Donald Trump
Republican · Executive
Purchase≥$1KAug 10Oct 8
Donald Trump
Republican · Executive
Purchase≥$1KJun 23Aug 22
Donald Trump
Republican · Executive
Sale≥$100KJun 12Aug 22
Donald Trump
Republican · Executive
Sale≥$1KJun 3Aug 22

Congressional trading data provided by QuiverQuant

See all
Product segmentsGeography
FY2025 · USD

How The Progressive turned $87.7B of revenue into $14.5B of operating income.

Revenue
Personal Lines Segment$71.8B▲ 17.80% YoY
Commercial Lines Segment$11.0B▲ 1.28% YoY
Total revenue$87.7B
Operating income$14.5B16.5%
See all